Anne (Waterman) Tillinghast was the widow of John or Charles Tillinghast when she married Thomas Hill as his third wife. They were married by Solomon Drowne, Justice.
Anne (Waterman) (Tillinghast) Hill died 1 Jan 1790 in her 95th year. Her parents are our ancestors, as is her brother John, who married Mercy Stafford.
Anne probably married her sister Mercy's widower, but this has not been confirmed.