Allen's second wife was Alma (Unknown). Allen and his brother Thomas settled at Ellisburgh, Jefferson Co., NY.
In both the 1860 and the 1870 Federal Census, Allen & Susan are living at Ellisburgh with their children Edmund & Mary. However, in 1860 their son is listed as Rufus (same estimated year of birth).
In the Federal Census of 1880, Allen & Susan are living at Ellisburgh, NY. With them are son Earl, and son Rufus and family.